Vendor security pages routinely say a company is CSA STAR certified, as if that were one fixed status. It is not. The Cloud Security Alliance's Security, Trust, Assurance and Risk programme has three levels, and the gap between the first and second is the entire point of the exercise: one is a vendor marking its own homework, the other requires an outside auditor to sign off. We pulled listings from the CSA STAR registry to see how many vendors actually sit at each level, and checked what a well-known cloud provider's own entry says against the shorthand its marketing uses.
What the CSA STAR registry actually contains
STAR is built around the Cloud Controls Matrix, a cybersecurity control framework for cloud computing maintained by the Cloud Security Alliance. The registry is the public list of organisations that have submitted evidence against that matrix. Entry is voluntary and the registry is free to search, which is why it has become a reference point in vendor questionnaires even though, as we covered in What Is CSA STAR, and Does It Actually Matter?, the bar for appearing on the list at all is low.
The registry does not grade vendors on a single pass or fail basis. Each entry carries a level, and the level determines whether anyone outside the vendor has actually looked at the control evidence. That distinction gets lost whenever a trust page simply states CSA STAR without saying which level, so it is worth setting out what each one actually requires.
Level 1 versus Level 2, the difference that matters
Level 1 is a self-assessment. A vendor completes the Consensus Assessments Initiative Questionnaire or the Cloud Controls Matrix itself, submits it, and the registry publishes it. Nobody independent checks the answers. It costs nothing beyond the time to fill in the form, and it can be submitted again whenever the vendor likes.
Level 2 requires an external party. There are two routes: STAR Attestation, which combines a SOC 2 examination with the Cloud Controls Matrix and is performed by a licensed CPA firm, and STAR Certification, which combines ISO/IEC 27001 with the Cloud Controls Matrix and is performed by an accredited certification body. Both involve independent testing of controls, not a questionnaire the vendor fills in alone. A separate China-focused scheme, C-STAR, follows a similar logic for that market. Level 3 exists for continuous monitoring but very few listings use it.
| Dimension | Level 1 | Level 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Who performs the assessment | The vendor itself | An accredited third party: CPA firm or certification body |
| Basis | CAIQ or CCM self-answers | SOC 2 plus CCM, or ISO 27001 plus CCM |
| Independent evidence testing | No | Yes |
| Typical renewal | Vendor's own schedule, often irregular | Annual audit or surveillance cycle |
| What a listing confirms | The vendor completed a questionnaire | An external auditor examined controls against a named standard |
The two levels answer different questions, and only one involves anyone outside the vendor checking the answers.
What we counted in the registry mirror
We pulled every active CSA STAR entry tracked in the CSA STAR registry mirror and tagged each by level. Because a vendor can hold more than one Level 2 sub-type at once, for example both a STAR Attestation and a STAR Certification, the Level 2 figures below do not sum neatly against Level 1.
- 61%
- of listings are Level 1 self-assessments with no Level 2 entry attached
- in the CertReports index on 2026-11-11
- 33%
- carry a Level 2 STAR Attestation (SOC 2 plus CCM)
- in the CertReports index on 2026-11-11
- 14%
- carry a Level 2 STAR Certification (ISO 27001 plus CCM)
- in the CertReports index on 2026-11-11
- 2%
- list a Level 3 continuous monitoring entry
- in the CertReports index on 2026-11-11
- Level 1 only61%self-assessment, no external audit
- Level 2 Attestation33%SOC 2 plus CCM, CPA firm
- Level 2 Certification14%ISO 27001 plus CCM, certification body
- Level 32%continuous monitoring, rare
Read against that baseline, a bare claim of CSA STAR on a trust page is closer to the norm than the exception, and it is the majority outcome rather than a red flag on its own. What matters is whether the vendor then names a Level 2 route, and whether the dated certificate or attestation the registry links to actually matches what the trust page claims.
Reading a listing correctly
- 1
Find the vendor on the registry
Search the official CSA STAR registry by legal entity name, since subsidiaries and brand names are often listed separately from the parent company.
- 2
Check the level field first
Every entry states Level 1, Level 2 or Level 3 explicitly. If a trust page just says CSA STAR with no level, treat that as Level 1 until you confirm otherwise.
- 3
For Level 2, identify the sub-type
Attestation and Certification are audited against different standards, SOC 2 versus ISO 27001, so check which one applies before assuming the control scope matches your own requirements. - 4
Check the assessment date
STAR Attestation follows the SOC 2 period it is based on, typically twelve months. STAR Certification follows the ISO 27001 surveillance cycle. An entry with no recent date is stale evidence, not current evidence.
- 5
Cross-check the claim against the entry
If the vendor's own CSA STAR framework page or trust centre says certified without naming a level, the registry entry itself is the tiebreaker, not the marketing copy.
AWS's registry entry against the marketing claim
Large cloud platforms are the vendors most likely to be waved through on a bare CSA STAR mention, because buyers assume a provider that size would not bother with anything less than the top tier. The registry entry is the way to check that assumption rather than accept it.
STAR Level 2 offers two options: STAR Certification, an independent assessment performed by an accredited certification body that measures control maturity against ISO/IEC 27001 and the Cloud Controls Matrix, and STAR Attestation, which integrates a SOC 2 examination with the Cloud Controls Matrix.
AWS's own entry on the registry lists a Level 2 STAR Attestation built on the SOC 2 examination, alongside a separate Level 2 STAR Certification tied to its ISO 27001 scope. That is a stronger position than a plain Level 1 listing, and it is consistent with the general marketing claim that AWS holds CSA STAR status. The detail buyers should still check is scope: a STAR Attestation or Certification covers the specific services and regions named in the underlying SOC 2 report or ISO 27001 certificate, not every AWS service by default, so the registry entry needs reading alongside the scope statement in the underlying report rather than taken as a blanket claim covering the whole platform.
Where buyers get this wrong
The trap is the word certified
An example of a trust centre next to its registry evidence
The card below pulls live data rather than a fixed snapshot, so look at the row the CSA STAR focus surfaces: whether the entry names a level, whether it points to Attestation or Certification, and whether the supporting SOC 2 or ISO 27001 evidence sits on the same page without a stated report type. That combination, evidence present but a detail missing, is the pattern worth checking on any vendor's page before taking a bare claim at face value.
Algolia · Trust report
Developer tools · Public evidence as of 26 Oct 2026
Framework overview
CertReports state for each framework with public evidence: 1 verified, 5 vendor-stated.
1Documents and agreements
Legal and review documents Algolia publishes or offers, as of 30 Sep 2026.
- Privacy policy · Public
How CSA STAR fits with the evidence buyers already check
CSA STAR rarely stands alone in a review. A Level 2 Attestation leans on the same SOC 2 examination a buyer would otherwise ask for directly, and a Level 2 Certification leans on the same ISO 27001 certificate. If you already know how to read a trust centre or how to compare SOC 2 against ISO 27001, you already have most of the skill needed to read a STAR Level 2 entry, because the underlying audit is the same document. The STAR layer mainly adds the Cloud Controls Matrix mapping on top, which is useful for cloud-specific control language but does not replace reading the underlying SOC 2 report or ISO 27001 certificate yourself when the contract is material.
People also ask
What is csa star level 2?
CSA STAR Level 2 is the tier of the Cloud Security Alliance's STAR programme that requires an independent third party to examine a vendor's controls, rather than the vendor answering a questionnaire alone. It has two main routes: STAR Attestation, based on a SOC 2 examination performed by a CPA firm, and STAR Certification, based on an ISO 27001 audit performed by an accredited certification body, both mapped against the Cloud Controls Matrix.
What is csa star level 1?
CSA STAR Level 1 is a self-assessment. The vendor completes the Consensus Assessments Initiative Questionnaire or the Cloud Controls Matrix itself and submits it to the registry without any external audit. It is free to complete, can be resubmitted at any time, and confirms only that the vendor answered the questions, not that anyone checked them.
What is csa star registry?
The CSA STAR registry is the Cloud Security Alliance's public, searchable list of organisations that have submitted security assessments against the Cloud Controls Matrix. Entries range from basic Level 1 self-assessments through audited Level 2 attestations and certifications to rare Level 3 continuous monitoring, and each one states its level and assessment date on the entry itself.
Is aws csa star certified?
AWS's registry entry lists a Level 2 STAR Attestation based on its SOC 2 examination and a separate Level 2 STAR Certification based on its ISO 27001 scope, which is a stronger position than a plain Level 1 listing. The detail to check is scope: the attestation and certification cover the specific services and regions named in the underlying reports, not every AWS service automatically.
Solomon Amos · Founder, CertReports
Solomon builds CertReports, the public evidence index for vendor security reviews. PhD in machine learning and cybersecurity, two years embedded at HMRC digital programmes, founder of TapTax. He writes about what registries, trust centres and auditors actually publish, and how buyers can use it before the questionnaire goes out.
Read next on CertReports
You might also like
Vendor Security Questionnaire Questions Answered by Public Evidence
Solomon Amos · 26 Sep 2026 · 8 min read